Thank you, Chair, and thank you to the members of the committee for inviting me to speak with you today.
My name is Keldon Bester and I’m the Executive Director of the Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project. We’re a think tank working to build an economy where markets work for the people who depend on them.
Though we are primarily focused on the topic of competition, consumer protection and competition go hand in hand. Fierce competition is often the first line of defense for the interests of consumers, with companies working hard to win and keep their customers.
To that end, one of the most important tasks of this committee is fostering and maintaining vibrant competition in the markets you oversee. This can occur both reactively through supporting strong enforcement of Canada’s merger laws, as well as proactively through policies to reduce the frictions that frustrate the competitive process. This committee has a history of leading important work on this front, work that has delivered material returns to Canadians. But progress is not permanent, and without a vigilant defense of competition the risk of backsliding persists.
Even in competitive markets, there is still a need for strong consumer protection policies to establish a floor for the standards Canadians can expect and to provide recourse for when those standards are not met. With responsibility shared with the provinces, the federal government has an important role to play in supporting competition and consumer protection, especially in federally regulated markets such as telecom, banking and transportation which tend toward oligopoly market structures.
But we would suggest that this role is not limited to these familiar sectors. Federal policymakers can also provide a strong defense of consumers through cross-cutting policy areas that have implications for markets across the economy.
For example, through oversight of the laws that govern privacy protections, federal policymakers have an important role to play in defending not just the privacy of Canadians, but also the concept of fair and open pricing, a foundational component of competition and consumer protection. Today, this concept is under threat by the rise of algorithmic pricing practices that have already provoked strong negative reactions from average Canadians. Whatever you call it – algorithmic pricing, surveillance pricing, personalized pricing – this practice of opaque, individualized prices based on personal data has the potential to undermine competition and may prove to be a defining consumer protection issue of our time.
Federal policymakers should also take a broader definition of consumers deserving protection, especially in the network and platform markets that increasingly make up the infrastructure of our economy. Here our definition of consumer should include individual Canadians as well as the businesses that depend on these services to compete for customers in their own markets. With this broader definition, consumer protection is not just about making sure that the average individual Canadian gets a fair deal, but also that Canadian businesses can thrive and innovate without being held back by the gatekeepers standing between them and their customers.
Complementing and building on the investigatory work of the Competition Bureau, federal policymakers can set the standards that keep competition open in these critical network and platform markets and ensure that consumers of all kinds can expect fair treatment in their commercial interactions.
The topic of consumer protection is a broad one, and there is no shortage of topics within its bounds for this committee to consider. With that in mind we summarize three frames that we believe can be helpful for this work:
First, the idea that defending and improving competition in the markets you oversee provides one of the strongest defenses of consumers.
Second, that cross-cutting areas of federal jurisdiction can be employed to protect the competitive process and the interests of consumers across the economy, not just in federally regulated sectors.
And third, that when we speak of protecting consumers, we also consider the businesses that depend on important economic infrastructure to provide high quality products and services to their own customers.
Thank you for your time and I look forward to your questions.
Subscribe to Letters from CAMP
Stay up to date on CAMP’s latest news, work and opportunities to get involved.
By subscribing, you consent to our Privacy Policy and to receive communications. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Stay Connected
Donate
Your contribution supports CAMP’s efforts to create a more democratic economy that works for all Canadians.
